Complexity of Safe Strategic Voting1
نویسندگان
چکیده
We investigate the computational aspects of safe manipulation, a new model of coalitional manipulation that was recently put forward by Slinko and White [11]. In this model, a potential manipulator v announces how he intends to vote, and some of the other voters whose preferences coincide with those of v may follow suit. Depending on the number of followers, the outcome could be better or worse for v than the outcome of truthful voting. A manipulative vote is called safe if for some number of followers it improves the outcome from v’s perspective, and can never lead to a worse outcome. In this paper, we study the complexity of finding a safe manipulative vote for a number of common voting rules, including Plurality, Borda, k-approval, and Bucklin, providing algorithms and hardness results for both weighted and unweighted voters. We also propose two ways to extend the notion of safe manipulation to the setting where the followers’ preferences may differ from those of the leader, and study the computational properties of the resulting extensions.
منابع مشابه
On the Theory of Strategic Voting1
In a plurality-rule election, a group of voters must coordinate behind one of two challengers in order to defeat a disliked status quo. Departing from existing work, the support for each challenger must be inferred from the private observation of informative signals. The unique equilibrium involves limited strategic voting and incomplete coordination. This is driven by negative feedback: an inc...
متن کاملFuture study of Description System Architecture Approaches with Emphasis on Strategic Management
Systems Architecture is a generic discipline to handle objects (existing or to be created) called systems, in a way that supports reasoning about the structural properties of these objects. Systems Architecture is a response to the conceptual and practical difficulties of the description and the design of complex systems. Systems Architecture is a generic discipline to handle objects (existin...
متن کاملAn Investigation into the Effects of Joint Planning on Complexity, Accuracy, and Fluency across Task Complexity
The current study aimed to examine the effects of strategic planning, online planning, strategic planning and online planning combined (joint planning), and no planning on the complexity, accuracy, and fluency of oral productions in two simple and complex narrative tasks. Eighty advanced EFL learners performed one simple narrative task and a complex narrative task with 20 minutes in between. Th...
متن کاملThe Complexity of Safe Manipulation under Scoring Rules
[Slinko and White, 2008] have recently introduced a new model of coalitional manipulation of voting rules under limited communication, which they call safe strategic voting. The computational aspects of this model were first studied by [Hazon and Elkind, 2010], who provide polynomial-time algorithms for finding a safe strategic vote under kapproval and the Bucklin rule. In this paper, we answer...
متن کاملNon-dictatorial Social Choice Rules Are Safely Manipulable
When a number of like-minded voters vote strategically and have limited abilities to communicate the under and overshooting may occur when too few or too many of them vote insincerely. In this paper we discuss this phenomenon and define the concept of a safe strategic vote. We prove that for any onto and non-dictatorial social choice rule there exist a profile at which a voter can make a safe s...
متن کامل